MERIDIAN CONSOLIDATED INDUSTRIESLESSONS PRESERVED
MCI / retained approaches

Retired ideas

Some approaches were useful for a time and later replaced by frameworks that could carry more observations.

1987–1994

Fixed Position Doctrine

Attempted: To keep a recorded location stable by treating movement as positional error.

Superseded: Field observations showed that ordinary use and access could establish a different expected position.

Legacy: The idea remains useful as a caution against confusing persistence with equivalence.

2004–2010

Sample-Only Neutrality

Attempted: To classify neutral finishes through an isolated material sample.

Superseded: Substrate and adjacent-field observations showed that a sample could not represent replacement behavior.

Legacy: Historical samples remain in the register as references, not complete classifications.

1998–2012

Activation-Only Review

Attempted: To judge a control primarily by travel, force and repeatability.

Superseded: Practitioners added response recognition and learned familiarity.

Legacy: Mechanical consistency remains a required observation within OAI.